Cover of The Tainted Cup by Robert Jackson Bennett

Hugo Award for Best Novel Winner 2025

The Tainted Cup

by Robert Jackson Bennett

Summary

Commander Taqtasa Blas, an imperial engineer, is found dead in a guest bedroom at a country house of the wealthy Haza clan, with leafy trees sprouting through his body. Dinios Kol, a junior investigator whose body has been altered so that he remembers everything he sees perfectly, is sent to look at the body and report every detail back to his superior, who will not leave the house.

That superior is Ana Dolabra, who wears a blindfold indoors because the world is too loud for her, eats constantly, insults everyone, and is known for solving cases without leaving her home. The arrangement is Holmes and Watson rebuilt so that the assistant is a recording instrument and the detective seldom attends the scene.

The setting is the reason to read it. The empire runs on engineered biology rather than machinery: people are altered for strength, speed and a range of mental gifts, plants and animals are routinely augmented too, and every wet season enormous creatures called leviathans come out of the sea and hit the sea walls, which is the only thing the whole state exists to survive. The deaths turn out to reach the engineers who keep those walls standing.

Din is the reason it has heart. He is provincial, poor, deeply unsure of himself, and quietly hiding a severe dyslexia and the fact that he cheated on the exams that got him the job, so every scene in which he performs perfect recall for his superior carries a private risk.

It is a proper fair play mystery, with clues laid out for the reader and a solution that does not cheat, wrapped in worldbuilding dense enough to reward slow reading, and it is very funny about bureaucracy and about the indignity of working for a genius.

Around four hundred pages and it moves. Best for readers who want detective fiction and fantasy at full strength simultaneously, and a good entry point for anyone who has never read either.

Historical Context & Significance

The Tainted Cup won the 2025 Hugo Award for Best Novel at Seattle Worldcon, and that November the World Fantasy Award for Best Novel at the convention in Brighton, over Kay Chronister's The Bog Wife, Lev Grossman's The Bright Sword, Yangsze Choo's The Fox Wife and Samantha Mills's The Wings Upon Her Back. Only two novels had won both prizes before it: Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell in 2005 and The City & the City in 2010.

Robert Jackson Bennett, born in Baton Rouge in 1984, had won the Shirley Jackson Award with his first novel, Mr. Shivers, and both the Divine Cities and the Founders trilogy had been Hugo finalists for best series. The Tainted Cup, a mystery on Holmes and Watson lines that Kirkus called a drawing room mystery, was also a finalist for the Edgar Award for Best Novel.

It is the first of the Shadow of the Leviathan series, followed by A Drop of Corruption in 2025 and A Trade of Blood in August 2026, each a new case for Ana and Din, and Locus found that this first book wraps up its own mystery satisfyingly while leaving the door open for more.

We may earn a commission if you buy through these links, at no extra cost to you.